DF 85 – Electricity in buildings LCA: State of the art, challenges, and ways ahead
With buildings, electricity consumption in construction, product manufacture and in the use phase is an important contributor to their environmental impacts. The forum will address electricity mix modelling issues in LCAs of buildings.
Several different models to represent the electricity consumed during the use phase of buildings are app¬lied in European countries: (1) the current national electricity consumer mix according to national statistics; (2) the electricity mix of the supplier, based on guarantees of origin (GO), (3) a (quasi dynamic) future electricity mix based on a national official energy scenario, (4) an individual electricity mix which covers the use profile of the building under assessment.
Companies in the supply chain of construction products purchase «green» electricity products to lower the environmental footprint of their products. These green electricity products are often based on GO or similar certification schemes. Physical production of electricity and electricity quality (GO) are then traded independently on different markets. This unique feature is a challenge for process based LCA.
The forum will discuss the following questions:
• What is the current state of electricity mix modelling for construction products and buildings’ use phases?
• How do different modelling approaches influence the transition of the electricity sector of a country to renewables?
• Which modelling approach is offered by leading LCA databases?
Breakout groups will allow for in depth discussions and identifying areas of consensus.
Programme: DF85-Programme.pdf
Videorecordings are available for free via this link: https://video.ethz.ch/events/lca/2023/autumn/85rd.html
A nice overview and summary of the event can be found in: Buildings & Cities.
8:30 | Registration, Coffee, Tea and Croissants |
|
A | Setting the scene | [Rolf Frischknecht, treeze] |
09:00 | Rolf Frischknecht, treeze | |
09:10 | The Swiss energy perspectives 2050+ and their correspondence in national and cantonal laws | Andreas Eckmanns |
09:30 | The market of Guarantees of Origin in Switzerland and Europe: strengths and weaknesses | Andrea Miksch, Pronovo |
09:50 | Electricity procurement and its consumption in buildings – a utility’s perspective | Gerhard Emch, ewz |
10:10 | Discussion |
|
10:30 | Coffee & Tea break |
|
B | Electricity mix modelling in European buildings LCA |
|
11:00 | The French electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects | Bruno Peuportier, Armines, France |
11:20 | The Danish electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects | Maria Balouktsi, Aalborg University, Denmark |
11:40 | The Norwegian electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects | Rolf André Bohne, NTNU, Norway |
12:00 | Discussion |
|
12:15 | Lunch |
|
C | Short presentations |
|
13:25 | Methodological aspects of calculating a national grid emission factor | Malte Schäfer TU Braunschweig |
13:35 | Marginal emissions factors for grid electricity use in consequential LCA studies for building energy systems (online presentation: pre-recorded) | Matt Roberts, Berkeley University |
D | Electricity mix modelling in Swiss buildings LCA |
|
13:45 | The KBOB electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects | Rolf Frischknecht, treeze Ltd |
14:00 | The University of Geneva electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects | Elliot Romano, Geneva University |
14:15 | The "EcoDynElec" electricity model for buildings LCA: characteristics and effects? | Sébastien Lasvaux, HEIG-VD |
14:30 | Martin Jakob, TEP Energy, Switzerland | |
14:50 | Discussion |
|
15:15 | Coffee & Tea break |
|
E | Electricity mixes suitable for buildings LCA |
|
15:45 | Discussion in breakout groups:
|
|
16:30 | Reporting back to plenary and discussion |
|
17:00 | Rolf Frischknecht | |
17:15 | End of 85th LCA Forum |
|